Gus Johnson played four sports as a Mustang. He was a three year starter in softball . He excelled in track at the All Island meet where he won Outstanding Performer his junior year. He led the basketball team in scoring two of his three years an accumulated 608 points. His sophomore season he helped to lead the Mustangs to defeat TAS in the first ever chopsticks game. Gus also played halfback on a soccer team that went 26-6 his three years.